fileg (fileg) wrote,

HASA Challenges

HASA has (yay!) started a forum where you can sign up to get challenge announcements by email I am hoping this will keep me from missing them in the flood of mail that sometimes overwhelms me there (though I miss that mail, too, and I hope to get caught up there as well. Must learn to skip what can be skipped, both here and there... compulsive, me.)

This confused me (and made me laugh) though:

Just before I left for NY on Monday,edrys sent me the latest challenge notice. (*smooches ness* thanks for helping me try to come back)

Message: There is now a new nuzgul in the hutch: "Lord of Men, Lord of

For two characters coming from such radically different backgrounds,
Faramir and Elrond actually have a lot in common:

* Elrond lost both of his parents when they sailed to Valinor, and his
brother when Elros chose mortality. Faramir lost his mother at a young age,
and his brother and father in the Ring War.

* Both are lore-masters.

* Both are acquainted with Mithrandir.

* Faramir leads a corps of rangers fighting orcs. Elrond's sons have been
fighting with a corps of rangers against the orcs.

* Both had the wisdom to know the Ring must be destroyed.

So just what would they have talked about when they met after the Ring War? Elrond surely has some good advice for Faramir to help him move beyond the pain the War had caused him. What did Faramir have to offer Elrond (some sort of reconciliation with Pippin? wisdom concerning Arwen's choice?)

I have actually been in this spot once or twice, but not in my canon arc. But I can't stop thinking about this line in the challenge description: What did Faramir have to offer Elrond (some sort of reconciliation with Pippin?

Am I missing something obvious? I cannot for my life think of what they would need to be reconciled about

Well, ok - when I talked about this with Chris, we ended up spinning a silly tale of how Pip romanced Elrond and dumped him when the fellowship went south. That awkward avoidance at Arwen's wedding, the bald-faced "I wrote you from Rohan, the letters must never have gotten delivered" excuses...

Really, though - Pip looms large in my own mythology. I will even admit to giving him some of the lines that were designed for North in order to get the concepts out there. I thought I had a handle on Pip. What am I missing?

  • Shall I shoot?

    I've mentioned before that there are things I understand (or think I understand) in Tolkien that I have just incorporated into myself without ever…

  • howard shaw

    The celebrated composer Howard Shore on the objects he can’t live without—including an imposing piece of armor gifted by director Peter Jackson

  • sting

    I just had another facepalm moment My excuse is, although I've been reading LOTR for more than half a century, I read it before I read The Hobbit…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.